Scorae › Rubrics › Peer Review Rubric (Grades 8-College)
Peer Review Rubric (Grades 8-College)
This rubric grades the feedback, not the paper it was written about. Give it to reviewers before a workshop so they know that 'good job, maybe add more detail' scores near zero, and use it to put a grade on the review itself. It works for written margin comments, a feedback letter, or a structured comment form, in any subject where students respond to each other's drafts.
- Grades 8-College
- Subject Cross-curricular
- 20 points
- 4 criteria
- Free to copy, print and adapt
| Criterion | Exceeds | Meets | Approaching | Beginning |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Specificity: Points to Exact Places in the Draft6 points | 6 ptsEvery comment names a location and quotes or paraphrases the exact words being discussed ('in paragraph 3 the sentence starting "Many people think" repeats your thesis'). | 5 ptsMost comments name a paragraph, sentence, or section so the writer can find the spot without asking. | 3-4 ptsComments describe a whole-paper impression ('the middle is confusing') without identifying which lines caused it. | 0-2 ptsComments are global verdicts ('nice essay,' 'needs work') that would fit any draft in the class unchanged. |
| Actionability: Tells the Writer What to Do Next6 points | 6 ptsEach concern is paired with a specific next move the writer could make in one revision session ('move this sentence to the top of the paragraph so it works as the topic sentence'). | 5 ptsMost concerns come with a suggestion or a question the writer could act on, even if the suggestion is broad. | 3-4 ptsNames problems but leaves the fix to the writer ('this part is unclear'), or suggests a change so large it cannot be done in a revision ('start over with a new topic'). | 0-2 ptsOnly corrects spelling and commas, or gives praise with no suggestion anywhere in the review. |
| Coverage: Addresses What the Assignment Asked For4 points | 4 ptsComments on every required focus area of the assignment (for example thesis, evidence, and organization) and states at least one thing that is working plus one to change. | 3 ptsComments on most required focus areas and includes both a strength and a concern. | 2 ptsComments on one focus area only, or offers praise with no concern raised anywhere. | 0-1 ptsIgnores the assignment's focus areas entirely, or fills the form with single words and blank fields. |
| Tone: Respectful and Directed at the Writing4 points | 4 ptsEvery criticism is aimed at the text rather than the person, uses reader-response phrasing ('I lost the thread here' rather than 'you're confusing'), and states praise as specifically as criticism. | 3 ptsComments stay neutral or warm and describe the writing, not the writer; no sarcasm or joking asides. | 2 ptsContains a blunt or dismissive phrase ('this makes no sense') or a joke at the writer's expense, even if the rest is civil. | 0-1 ptsIncludes insults, mocking, or a refusal to engage ('I don't know, it's fine I guess'). |
Total: 20 points across 4 criteria.
How to use it
- Show two sample reviews of the same anonymous draft, one scoring 18 and one scoring 6, before students review anything. The contrast teaches specificity faster than any explanation.
- Grade the review as its own assignment in the gradebook. If the reviewer's grade depends on the writer's draft quality, students learn that reviewing carefully does not pay.
- Specificity and Actionability carry 12 of the 20 points on purpose: a kind, thorough review that cannot be acted on does not help the writer.
- For college or AP, add a required word floor (say 150 words per review) rather than adding a fifth criterion, so the four levels stay quick to score.
What students most often get wrong
- Proofreading instead of reviewing: circling every comma and never mentioning the thesis or the structure.
- Writing only praise to avoid conflict, which leaves the writer with nothing to revise and scores low on both Actionability and Coverage.
- Reviewing the topic rather than the draft ('I agree that school should start later') without saying anything about how the argument is built.
Grade with this rubric, without retyping it
Scorae applies a rubric to student work in Google Docs, Canvas, Blackboard and Moodle, and drafts criterion-by-criterion feedback. You review and decide every grade — nothing is submitted for you. Student work is never stored.
Add to Chrome — freeFree plan: 15 essays a month, no card. Works on desktop Chrome.